Theatre in Brooklyn September




Reliable & Guaranteed Tickets

We have a 100% Buyer Guarantee + your tickets will be legitimate, arrive in time for the event, and be completely refunded if the event is cancelled*.

*If your experience falls short of these expectations, you're covered by our 100% money-back guarantee.

*Ticketsbrooklyn.com is an independent ticket guide, unaffiliated with venues. Prices may be above or below face value. No hidden fees.


Filter by Date Clear
Thu Sep 3 11:00am
The Gazillion Bubble Show
New World Stages: Stage 2  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 1:00pm
Beaches - A New Musical
Majestic Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 2:00pm
Heathers - The Musical
New World Stages: Stage 1  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 2:00pm
The Gazillion Bubble Show
New World Stages: Stage 2  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 2:00pm
Gotta Dance
Stage 42  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 3:00pm
Oh, Mary!
Lyceum Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 5:00pm
Celebrity Autobiography
Shubert Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Little Shop Of Horrors
Westside Theatre Upstairs  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Hadestown
Walter Kerr Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
The Lost Boys
Palace Theatre New York City  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
The Great Gatsby - A New Musical
Broadway Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
The Outsiders
Bernard B. Jacobs Theater  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Schmigadoon!
Nederlander Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Hamilton
Richard Rodgers Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Wicked
Gershwin Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Buena Vista Social Club - Musical
Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Harry Potter and The Cursed Child
Lyric Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Marquis Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Death Becomes Her
Lunt  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Beaches - A New Musical
Majestic Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
MJ - The Musical
Neil Simon Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
The Play That Goes Wrong
New World Stages: Stage 4  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Just in Time
Circle In The Square Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Chicago - The Musical
Ambassador Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Six The Musical
Lena Horne Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
New World Stages: Stage 3  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Operation Mincemeat
John Golden Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Maybe Happy Ending - A New Musical
Belasco Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
& Juliet
Stephen Sondheim Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Jamie Allan's Amaze
New World Stages: Stage 5  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
The Book Of Mormon
Eugene O'Neill Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Chess: The Musical
Imperial Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Cats: The Jellicle Ball
Broadhurst Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Richard O'Brien's The Rocky Horror Show
Studio 54  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Paranormal Activity - Play
Virginia/August Wilson Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
Aladdin
New Amsterdam Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
The Lion King
Minskoff Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:00pm
An American Daughter
Irene Diamond Stage at Signature Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:30pm
Heathers - The Musical
New World Stages: Stage 1  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:30pm
Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York)
Longacre Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:30pm
Oh, Mary!
Lyceum Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 7:30pm
Titanique - Musical
St. James Theatre  •  New York, NY
Thu Sep 3 9:00pm
Celebrity Autobiography
Shubert Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Little Shop Of Horrors
Westside Theatre Upstairs  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Hadestown
Walter Kerr Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
The Lost Boys
Palace Theatre New York City  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
The Great Gatsby - A New Musical
Broadway Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
The Outsiders
Bernard B. Jacobs Theater  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Schmigadoon!
Nederlander Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Hamilton
Richard Rodgers Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Wicked
Gershwin Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Buena Vista Social Club - Musical
Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Harry Potter and The Cursed Child
Lyric Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Marquis Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Death Becomes Her
Lunt  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Beaches - A New Musical
Majestic Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
MJ - The Musical
Neil Simon Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
The Play That Goes Wrong
New World Stages: Stage 4  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Just in Time
Circle In The Square Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Six The Musical
Lena Horne Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
New World Stages: Stage 3  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Heathers - The Musical
New World Stages: Stage 1  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Maybe Happy Ending - A New Musical
Belasco Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Jamie Allan's Amaze
New World Stages: Stage 5  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
The Book Of Mormon
Eugene O'Neill Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Chess: The Musical
Imperial Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Cats: The Jellicle Ball
Broadhurst Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Richard O'Brien's The Rocky Horror Show
Studio 54  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
Aladdin
New Amsterdam Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
The Lion King
Minskoff Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:00pm
An American Daughter
Irene Diamond Stage at Signature Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:30pm
Operation Mincemeat
John Golden Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:30pm
Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York)
Longacre Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:30pm
Oh, Mary!
Lyceum Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:30pm
Titanique - Musical
St. James Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:30pm
Celebrity Autobiography
Shubert Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 7:30pm
Gotta Dance
Stage 42  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 8:00pm
Chicago - The Musical
Ambassador Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 8:00pm
& Juliet
Stephen Sondheim Theatre  •  New York, NY
Fri Sep 4 8:00pm
Paranormal Activity - Play
Virginia/August Wilson Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 11:00am
The Gazillion Bubble Show
New World Stages: Stage 2  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 1:00pm
Hamilton
Richard Rodgers Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 1:00pm
Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Marquis Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Little Shop Of Horrors
Westside Theatre Upstairs  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Hadestown
Walter Kerr Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
The Lost Boys
Palace Theatre New York City  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
The Great Gatsby - A New Musical
Broadway Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
The Outsiders
Bernard B. Jacobs Theater  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Wicked
Gershwin Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Buena Vista Social Club - Musical
Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Harry Potter and The Cursed Child
Lyric Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Schmigadoon!
Nederlander Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Death Becomes Her
Lunt  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Beaches - A New Musical
Majestic Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
MJ - The Musical
Neil Simon Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
The Play That Goes Wrong
New World Stages: Stage 4  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Just in Time
Circle In The Square Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
New World Stages: Stage 3  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Operation Mincemeat
John Golden Theatre  •  New York, NY
Sat Sep 5 2:00pm
Heathers - The Musical
New World Stages: Stage 1  •  New York, NY


Theatre in Brooklyn September 2026 schedule

September in Brooklyn promises an exciting lineup of shows and events for entertainment enthusiasts. Fans of comedy can look forward to the 'Comedy Tonight: BYOB Stand-Up Showcase' scheduled for Tuesday, September 29, 2026, at 8:00 PM at BK Made Comedy, offering a night of hilarious performances from some of the city's best stand-up comedians. Music lovers and theatergoers can enjoy the captivating performance of 'Gromkie' on Sunday, September 20, 2026, at 7:00 PM at the Oceana Theater, providing an engaging experience in a top Brooklyn venue. Throughout September, Brooklyn's vibrant venues and diverse performers make it an ideal destination for entertainment, ensuring there's something for everyone seeking memorable shows and performances.